Thursday, 6 October 2011

Should she go ahead with this marriage or not?


I am a young Muslim woman with a good heart and I am righteous in all my actions. Fate decreed that I should become engaged to my cousin, whom I did not know before because he lives in America. I got to know him a little when he visited our country, and after that he left. We have gotten engaged and we agreed to get married in eight months' time, so that I can finish my studies, but after he left and we got in touch with one another, we began to disagree about many matters. Every time we phone one another it only ends in feeling upset, and he is not the person that I knew before; he has changed completely. We have thought about separating, but our relatives have interfered and prevented a divorce. But the relationship did go back to what it was at first. I am confused about what to do – should I go ahead or cancel it?.

Praise be to Allaah.


If your cousin is righteous and adheres to his religion,
prays regularly and is of good character, then do not hasten to seek a
separation. Many minor differences can be dealt with and an understanding
can be reached. It may need some time in order to get used to one another
and become comfortable with one another. But the most important matter is
his relationship with his Lord, may He be glorified and exalted, and his
adherence to his religion. The one who is religious will help his family to
obey Allaah and will being them closer to pleasing Allaah. Such a person is
usually trustworthy, for his religious commitment will prevent him from
mistreating his family or being unjust, especially if you travel with him
and go to live far from your family. But if he is careless with regard to
his religious commitment and does not pray regularly, and is not known to be
righteous and upright, then undoubtedly marriage to him is a dangerous
matter, because the one who is negligent towards his religious commitment
will be more negligent in other matters; if a person neglects the rights of
his Lord and Creator, it will come as no surprise that he neglects the
rights of others. Leaving one who is like this now is better than leaving
him later, before the marriage is consummated and any children are born. 

You have to pray istikhaarah, for the one who seeks guidance
from his Lord and prays istikhaarah cannot lose. And consult righteous
people among your family who know about your husband and his character and

For more information on praying istikhaarah, please see
questions no. 11981 and

You should strive to equip yourself with the best of
characteristics and attitudes, for both spouses are enjoined to do that. The
problem may also be due to you as well. Perhaps your husband has complaints
about your attitude and behaviour just as you have about his. We ask Allaah
to set your affairs straight and to make good easy for you wherever it is. 


In your question you say "fate decreed". This is a grave
error, for fate has no will. What you should say is "Allaah willed" or
"Allaah decreed". 

Shaykh Ibn 'Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) was
asked about saying, "circumstances dictated that such and such should
happen" or "fate decreed that such and such should happen." 

He replied:  

Saying "fate willed" or "circumstances willed" are
reprehensible phrases, because circumstances or time have no will, and fate
has no will. Rather the One who wills and decrees is Allaah, may He be
exalted and glorified. It would be better for a person to say: "The decree
of Allaah dictated that such and such should happen." There is nothing wrong
with that. But it is not permissible to attribute will to fate. End quote. 

Majmoo' Fataawa Ibn 'Uthaymeen,

And Allaah knows best.

No comments:

Post a Comment